Clearly Filtered vs Aquatru

TL;DR

AquaTru wins overall for buyers who want RO-level filtration, especially when fluoride and broader contaminant reduction are high priorities. Clearly Filtered is the better pick if you want the simplest everyday option for an apartment, dorm, office, or rental where no power, no plumbing, and easy portability matter more than maximum filtration depth.

Clearly Filtered vs Aquatru: Side by Side

This comparison is really about filter type first. Clearly Filtered is a gravity pitcher, while AquaTru is a countertop reverse osmosis system, so they solve different problems even if both are aimed at people who want better-tasting drinking water and wider contaminant reduction than a basic faucet filter.

For most shoppers, the deciding factor is whether you want convenience or deeper treatment. A pitcher is easier to live with day to day, while RO is usually the stronger path when dissolved contaminants and fluoride are major concerns. As a general buying rule, it is smarter to compare certifications and treatment standards than marketing contaminant counts alone. The NSF water filter standards page is a good place to understand why NSF/ANSI 42, 53, 58, and 401 are not interchangeable, and the NSF certified drinking water treatment database can help you verify specific claims.

Clearly Filtered Water Filter Pitcher, 10 Cup BPA Free

Best for: renters, dorms, offices, and small kitchens where you want filtered water in an apartment with no under-sink access and no interest in dealing with power cords, drain lines, or wastewater.

The Good

• Targets many contaminants in a simple gravity-pitcher format
• Fridge-friendly design makes it easier to fit into tight spaces
• No electricity, plumbing, or permanent installation required
• Buyer reviews often praise taste improvement
• Easier to move between apartments or temporary living setups

The Bad

• Not the same filtration category as reverse osmosis for fluoride-focused buyers
• Some complaints mention cleaning being more involved than expected
• May be less ideal for some well-water situations without first testing the water

One verified buyer summed up the convenience case well: “I no longer need to buy the numerous 3 L bottles of spring water I’ve been getting for decades, lugging them from the supermarket every week.” — verified buyer, 5 stars

Our Take: Clearly Filtered is the smarter buy if your real-world need is easy, portable filtration for everyday city water use, not a larger RO appliance with higher cost and more upkeep.

AQUATRU Classic Alkaline Countertop Water Purifier

Best for: households concerned about fluoride or broader dissolved-contaminant reduction in municipal water, especially when you have enough counter space and are comfortable with a more involved countertop RO setup.

The Good

• Countertop RO purification is the main reason to choose it over a pitcher
• Buyer reviews frequently mention better taste
• Easy setup and use are mentioned in customer experience
• No permanent plumbing installation is typically needed for this style of system
• RO systems are generally the stronger fit when fluoride reduction is a top priority

The Bad

• Takes significant counter space compared with a pitcher
• Higher upfront price than Clearly Filtered
• RO ownership usually means more maintenance and wastewater than pitcher filtration

A verified buyer captured the value tradeoff this way: “The price is high but worth not buying and lugging bottles of water.” — verified buyer, 5 stars

Our Take: AquaTru is the better overall choice if your buying decision starts with stronger filtration performance and fluoride reduction, and you can accept the bigger footprint, higher cost, and more involved maintenance.

Which One Should You Buy?

Buy Clearly Filtered if you live in a rental, dorm, or shared home where installation is a nonstarter and you just want a low-fuss way to keep filtered drinking water in the fridge. This is the better fit for people who move often, have limited counter space, or do not want another plugged-in appliance.

Buy AquaTru if fluoride reduction is a major reason you are shopping and you want RO technology instead of a standard pitcher approach. In most head-to-head situations, AquaTru makes more sense for buyers who are trying to solve a water-quality concern first and a convenience problem second.

Buy Clearly Filtered if your household drinks a moderate amount of water and values speed of use more than depth of treatment. Fill it, let it filter, and pour from the fridge or counter. For a one- or two-person household in an apartment kitchen, that simpler routine may be more realistic than maintaining an RO unit.

Buy AquaTru if you are willing to trade space and simplicity for broader reduction capability. If you already know your tap water has issues you care about beyond taste, or you have reviewed your local utility report and want a more aggressive treatment approach, the extra cost and ownership demands may be worth it. If you use a private well, start with the EPA private wells guide and CDC healthy water wells before choosing either system, because untreated well-water issues can require more targeted treatment than a pitcher or countertop RO alone.

Pause before buying either one if you are comparing only on contaminant-count marketing. Evidence indicates that certification scope matters more than a headline number. Buyers should also check local water data through EPA consumer confidence reports and compare that against each system’s verified standards and maintenance burden.

FAQ

Is AquaTru better than Clearly Filtered for fluoride?

Usually yes. Reverse osmosis is generally the stronger technology when fluoride reduction is a key goal, which is why AquaTru has the edge here. Clearly Filtered may still appeal if you want a simpler pitcher, but if fluoride is non-negotiable, AquaTru is the more logical direction.

Is Clearly Filtered worth it if AquaTru removes more?

Yes, if your main goal is convenient filtered water without installation, electricity, wastewater, or a large countertop footprint. Plenty of buyers do not need RO-level treatment and would rather have something easy to fill, store, and carry. In a small apartment kitchen, that everyday convenience can matter more than having the deepest treatment category.

Is AquaTru worth the extra money over Clearly Filtered?

It is worth the extra money when you are specifically paying for RO filtration and the stronger fluoride-focused performance that usually comes with it. It is probably not worth it if your main frustrations are taste, chlorine, and buying bottled water, and you would be annoyed by the larger footprint and maintenance routine.

Does AquaTru require more maintenance than Clearly Filtered?

Yes. A countertop RO system typically involves more filter stages, more parts, and reject water, so day-to-day ownership is more involved than using a gravity pitcher. Clearly Filtered is simpler to live with, though you still need to replace filters on schedule to keep performance where it should be.

Which one is better for small spaces?

Clearly Filtered is usually the easier fit. A fridge-friendly pitcher works better in dorms, rentals, offices, and compact kitchens, while AquaTru needs dedicated counter space and access to power.

Should I compare contaminant counts or certifications first?

Certifications first. A big contaminant-count claim does not tell you whether those reductions were independently certified under the same standards. Start with NSF water filter standards, then verify specific listings in the NSF certified drinking water treatment database where possible.

What if I am on well water?

Do not buy either one based on marketing alone. Well water can involve nitrates, arsenic, PFAS, hardness, iron, sulfur, or microbial issues that need targeted treatment, so testing comes first. The EPA private wells guide and EPA national drinking water regulations are useful starting points for understanding what to test for and why.

Can a pitcher like Clearly Filtered replace bottled water for most households?

For many small households, yes. Buyer reviews suggest that convenience and taste are strong reasons people switch from bottled water to a pitcher. The bigger question is whether a pitcher’s lower throughput and simpler format match your water use and the contaminants you are trying to address.

Bottom Line

AquaTru is the overall winner because RO filtration is usually the stronger answer for buyers who care about fluoride and broader contaminant reduction. Clearly Filtered still wins for the buyer who wants the easiest possible setup in a small space, with no power, no plumbing, and no RO-style maintenance. Choose based on the kind of system you want to live with every day, not just which brand makes the biggest claim.

Affiliate disclosure: Some links in this article are affiliate links. We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.